Apple said, We upped our photo-management system…now up yours!
[This is a rant that needed to be written seven months ago, when the event actually happened, but nothing would have changed if it had. I know that, you know that, and Tim Cook knows that. — Ed.]
It is one thing to introduce a new application that does something “better” and expect (or demand) users to adopt it. But to introduce a new application and cripple an existing one is underhanded, arrogant, and one of the most disturbing trends in software today.
I speak of the tool I have used extensively for years and has been an integral part of the work for this website, iPhoto and specifically its Places tool. To make this clear from the outset: I use iPhoto strictly as an organizational tool. I do my work in GraphicConverter, the venerated Swiss Army Knife of image utilities. But now, the ability to pin photo locations on a map has been taken from me.
The introduction of Places in iPhoto ’09 was itself a compelling reason to get a new computer. At the time, I had 13,500 photos dating back to June 2001. I had keywords created for the counties I had the most photos in, but I had also taken trips to Virginia and in Florida in the previous 18 months. I could now pinpoint where I was when I took each photo and not only have a big map to show for it, but effortlessly call up every photo I had ever taken near a given location. After two months of work, the national map looked like this:

Continue reading →