
November 19, 2010: What do you want on your tombstone trophy? (Center: Sara Stoakes, one-woman championship.)
The state high school softball tournament was last week — AGWSR won its first title in that sport — and the baseball tournament is this week. (Actually, it started at the end of last week, with Mason City Newman routing Gladbrook-Reinbeck.) While state tournament memories last a lifetime and the participation is about more than the hardware, Iowa’s postseason trophies are now universally generic and lack the luster they used to have.
On the girls’ side, the trophies at best look like wooden J.D. Power awards but also bear a striking similarity to tombstones. This has been the case since 2007-08, when styles in use for decades were supplanted by rectangular slabs dominated by the IGHSAU logo*. It wasn’t always like this; Everly’s girls’ basketball trophy from 1968** is half the height of the participants themselves and the following style wasn’t bad at all.
Starting this past year, the boys followed suit. They have gone from this and this and this and this, large and regal pieces that leave no question about what sport they’re from, to trapezoidal slabs that say “State Participant” for everyone except the top two teams and a champion’s trophy just like a quarterfinalist’s. No matter the sport, they ALL look the same.
I can only guess that this move was done for financial purposes, that bulk-ordering trophies that are entirely identical except maybe for one line and placing a thin sheet of metal on them with the specifics is cheaper than trophies of different shapes with different figures on them. I want to believe that because otherwise the change — even or especially for the sake of change — doesn’t make sense.
This needs to be fixed, and I think I have an idea on how to make it happen. Read on. Continue reading →